Are you kidding me? They BOTH suck ass!!!! Hilary duff is just as bad. She can't sing, act, or breath without making me anyone around her sick!!!!!! she's horrible! I wish she oculd go back to acting, cause that way i could at least change the channel. Now, shes everywhere! magazines, tv, radio! its horrible! makes me wanna find her and duck tape her to teh ceiling and leave her there to rot!!!!